Cherreads

Chapter 4 - Chapter 2: The Price of Justice

Hours after my silent escape to the library, the dawn light began to filter lazily through the wide windows, tinting the dust suspended in the air with a soft golden halo. Despite the promise of a new day, my eyes remained glued to the pages of my book, seeking refuge in another's words. Suddenly, a deafening crash echoed from downstairs, jolting me from my reverie like an electric shock. The violent, metallic sound of dishes crashing against the floor mingled with high-pitched, heart-rending screams, the unmistakable voices of my little nieces. An icy chill ran down my spine, contracting every muscle in my body. My heart began to pound wildly, a furious drumbeat echoing in my ears. A murky mix of stabbing anxiety about what might be happening and a steely determination drove me to slam the book down on the table and run to the kitchen.

As I reached the threshold, the scene that unfolded before my eyes was absolute chaos. The pale tiled floor was now covered in an uneven carpet of food scraps: pieces of yellowish tortilla, chunks of bright red tomato, and fragments of bread scattered like shrapnel. The twins, their usually angelic little faces now contorted with fury, jumped and kicked with uncontrolled energy, their small fists punching the air. In the midst of this whirlwind of childish rage, Mrs. Álvarez, her weathered face marked by years of patience, tried to calm them with almost ethereal gentleness, her wrinkled hands moving with slow, reassuring gestures, though her eyes reflected deep fatigue. One of the girls, her lower lip trembling with visceral contempt, pointed an accusatory finger at the remains of food scattered at her feet and exclaimed in a high-pitched, bile-filled voice, "This is disgusting! I don't want to eat this!" Her twin sister joined the chorus of protests, her screams echoing with similar frustration.

I approached them cautiously, feeling the palpable tension in the air like an invisible barrier. My voice, though directed at the girls, was firm, trying to cut through the rising hysteria. "What's going on here?" The girls turned their reddened faces toward me, their small eyes shining with a childish but intense rage, like two cornered wild beasts. In that instant, observing their faces contorted with anger and frustration on Mrs. Alvarez's face, I understood that this was beyond a simple morning tantrum. It was a blatant display of disrespect, not only toward Mrs. Alvarez, who had taken the time to prepare her meal, but toward the food itself, a disregard that made my stomach churn.

At that moment, as if summoned by the scandal, Esperanza suddenly appeared in the doorway, her elegant figure tense and her usually haughty face now contorted with cold, controlled anger. Her dark eyes glared at the scene before fixing me with disdain. "Stay out of what doesn't concern you, Josephine," she hissed, each word laced with venom. Then, without even granting me another glance, she turned to Mrs. Alvarez, her voice dripping with contempt and superiority: "How dare you cook something my girls don't like!" A wave of hot anger flooded me, coursing through my veins with surprising intensity. Esperanza, always so self-centered and cruel, seemed ready to blame an older, hardworking woman, who had always shown kindness to everyone, for the simple spoiled whims of her daughters. With a swift, instinctive movement, I physically placed myself between my sister and Mrs. Alvarez, like a small protective shield. "Esperanza, stop!" my voice echoed in the kitchen with a firmness that surprised even me, a newfound determination that stemmed from indignation. "I won't allow you to treat her like this."

Esperanza let out a dry, mocking laugh, her thin lips curling into a contemptuous smile. "And who do you think you are, ordering me around?" Her eyes scrutinized me from head to toe, as if I were an insignificant speck of dust that needed to be swept away.

"I'm your sister," I retorted, my voice trembling slightly but maintaining its firmness, "and I won't allow you to mistreat someone like that. Mrs. Alvarez is just doing her job, and it's not her fault your daughters are so rude and spoiled."

My sister's eyes narrowed, hatred gleaming in their dark depths. "Stay out of your own business. This is the last time I'm warning you, Josephine. And let it be clear: my daughters' upbringing is my business." Every word was a veiled threat, a reminder of my place in this family hierarchy.

With suppressed fury, Esperanza took a step toward Mrs. Álvarez, raising a hand in a threatening gesture, as if she were about to slap her. Without a second thought, my body reacted before my mind. I gripped her wrist tightly, my fingers pressing into her skin with unexpected determination. "Don't even think about touching her," I snapped, my voice now visibly shaking with anger and adrenaline. My sister stared at me in disbelief and blind fury, her eyes bloodshot. "Let me go, Josephine! This is a private matter. A 12-year-old brat isn't going to come into my house to tell me how I should treat my servants, much less how I should raise my daughters." Her voice rose in a hysterical scream, completely losing the composure she was trying so hard to maintain. "It's not a private matter when it comes to mistreating someone," I retorted with surprising firmness, maintaining my grip on her wrist. "I may be 11 years old, as you say, but I'm still much more mature than you, and I know that no human being deserves to be treated this way. Besides, these girls need to learn to respect others, and you're the first one who should set the example."

I abruptly let go of her hand, feeling a chill run down my arm as it was released from my trembling grasp. I faced her directly, my eyes boring into hers. "Do you know what bothers me the most? The injustices, especially because she's a human being, and the way you treat her is inhumane. And you know what's the most ironic thing? That woman was your nanny—your nanny! How can you treat someone who took care of you when you were little like that? Before you hurt other human beings, learn to raise your daughters properly."

Esperanza froze for a moment, her face showing a mixture of surprise and disbelief. Then, a mocking, venomous smile slowly spread across her lips. "You, lecturing me on morals? You're the last person who should be talking!"

I took a step closer to her, my voice now firm and resonant. "Yes, that's me. And I'm proud of it. Unlike you, I have values, and I find it strange because it doesn't seem like we were raised the same way or had the same parents."

At that moment, Esperanza's mask of mockery vanished, replaced by blind, uncontrollable rage. With a strangled scream, she lunged at me, her hand slamming into my cheek with brutal force that sent me reeling backward, my head thudding against the sharp edge of the counter with a dull ache. Just at that moment, as if the universe had been waiting for the climax of the confrontation, my parents entered the kitchen, their faces reflecting a mixture of confusion and deep annoyance at having been interrupted by such a scandal.

"Mom, Dad!" Esperanza's high-pitched, indignant voice ricocheted off the white tiled walls of the kitchen, slicing through the thick air with its sharp edge. Her eyes, flashing with theatrical rage, bore into our parents, seeking their unconditional support. She pointed an accusatory finger at me, her upper lip trembling slightly, denouncing my "insolence" as if I had committed the worst betrayal. "Josephine is discrediting me in front of the maid! She says I'm treating her badly and that I should raise my daughters better. It's incredible how she butts into my business!" Each word was a lash, directed not only at me but also at Mrs. Álvarez, humiliating her even further by referring to her as a mere "maid."

With a firm voice, even though a painful lump tightened in my throat, I responded, keeping my gaze on Esperanza's cold eyes: "I just can't allow you to mistreat someone like that. She's just doing her job and doesn't deserve to be treated that way, much less because of your daughters' whims."

My parents exchanged quick, expressionless glances, their faces as inscrutable as stone masks. My father finally broke the silence with an icy voice, devoid of all warmth: "Josephine Leal, how many times do I have to warn you not to meddle in your sister's business? And how come you're defending a filthy servant?"

I felt an icy chill run down my spine, a knot of anguish tightening in my stomach. I knew this reaction was expected, almost predictable, but the stabbing indignation still hurt. I'd always been the black sheep of the family, the one who dared to question the rules, the one who stood up for those without a voice. I sighed deeply, mentally preparing myself for the coming storm.

"But it's not fair!" I exclaimed, my voice trembling slightly, betraying my growing agitation. "She's a human being, and she deserves to be respected!"

My father frowned impatiently, his thick eyebrows knitting together over the bridge of his nose. "Josephine, don't be dramatic. Esperanza is your older sister and deserves respect. And you should learn to stay out of other people's business."

My mother, a look of deep disappointment etched on her elegant features, approached me and took my arm with unusual firmness. "You have to understand, Josephine, that Esperanza is the owner of this house and has the right to discipline and treat her employees as she pleases. You can't come here and tell her how to behave."

I broke free from his grasp with a jerky movement, feeling my heart beat at breakneck speed, like a bird trapped in a cage. "Discipline? That's what they call discipline? That's abuse!"

The air in the kitchen grew thick and heavy, laden with an almost palpable tension. My parents watched me with a mixture of cold anger and deep, silent disappointment. Esperanza, at my side, wore a small, triumphant smile, savoring every word that came out of my mouth like it was sweet nectar. Mrs. Álvarez, her eyes red and swollen from crying, clung to my presence like a lifeline in the midst of a raging sea. I turned to her briefly and, in a barely audible whisper, told her to leave the kitchen; she had no reason to witness this. Just at that moment, my father's authoritarian voice thundered through the air.

"We've had enough of this! Go to your room," he snapped, his voice reverberating in my ears like distant thunder.

I shook my head stubbornly, feeling physically unable to keep quiet, to swallow the indignation burning inside me. "How can you be so cruel? She's a human being, not an object!" My voice trembled, but the determination inside me remained unshaken.

Esperanza let out a mocking and condescending, "Oh, how noble you are!"

"I don't understand why it's so difficult for you to have respect for others, no matter who they are," I retorted, my frustration growing with every word.

"Of course! You think you're so much better than everyone else," Esperanza countered, venom in her tone.

My heart pounded painfully, each beat resonating with the blatant injustice of the situation. How could they be so blind? How could they justify humiliating and mistreating another person? "I believe no one should be treated with disrespect, not even the maid."

Esperanza let out a high-pitched, ironic laugh. "Ah, servants! What a noble cause you've chosen to champion. Why don't we offer you a reward? Perhaps a medal for your bravery?"

My mother, with a soft but firm voice tinged with tired resignation, tried to calm me, though her words had the opposite effect. "Josephine, dear, we understand your sensitivity, but you must understand that certain social hierarchies are inevitable."

My mother's words cut deeper than any physical slap. How could my own parents defend such an injustice, perpetuate such an archaic and cruel worldview? "That's what I don't understand! Why do we have to treat someone worse just because they do housework?"

Esperanza, with a cruel, calculating smile that chilled my blood, made a proposal that left me breathless. "If you're so keen to experience the maid's treatment, we can make a small trade. You take care of her chores, and she can enjoy your privileges. What do you think?"

Anger flooded me like a black tide, obscuring my vision and clenching my fists. How dare they suggest something so humiliating and absurd?

My father, finally losing what little patience he had left, strode toward me with firm steps and delivered a sharp, painful slap that sent me reeling. "Go right now and do all of that maid's chores, for from this moment on, she's fired. Now you'll be in charge of all her duties for being a defender."

Tears flowed uncontrollably from my eyes, a bitter mixture of physical pain and a deep sense of injustice, cruelty, and humiliation. I got up from the floor, staggering and disoriented, and headed for the door, feeling every accusing stare fixed on my back.

As I crossed the threshold, I met Mrs. Alvarez, waiting for me in the hallway, her eyes filled with fear and silent gratitude. We hugged tightly, finding a brief mutual solace amidst so much injustice. "Thank you, miss. No one has ever done anything like this for me," she whispered, her voice cracking with emotion.

"You don't have to thank me. No one deserves to be treated like this," I replied, my voice still trembling, feeling the weight of her gratitude and the bitterness of my own helplessness.

As I left the house, the coolness of the night air hit my face like an invisible slap, a stinging contrast to the stifling atmosphere of the kitchen. Every cell in my body trembled with adrenaline and outrage. I felt as if I had just escaped from a tangible nightmare, where cruelty and injustice reigned unashamed. My cheeks burned with a stinging fire, the physical echo of the slaps I'd received, and a dull, stabbing pain radiated from the base of my skull, reminding me of the violent blow I'd had against the counter. A boiling anger bubbled inside me, a volcano about to erupt, but beneath that rage throbbed a deep sadness, a sense of desolation at my own family's brutality. I couldn't believe the vileness of what had just happened, the coldness with which they had defended the indefensible.

Amid my daze, I spotted the imposing figure of one of the bodyguards discreetly patrolling the grounds of the mansion. Taking advantage of his proximity, I gathered what little composure I had left. In a voice I tried to keep calm and even, striving to appear normal, something I didn't feel at all, I asked him for a huge favor. I explained that I needed a journal as soon as possible and begged him to discreetly leave it on the desk in my room when I had it. His expressionless face betrayed no emotion, but he nodded slightly, a small spark of hope igniting in my chest at his silent acceptance.

"Of course! You think you're so much better than everyone else," Esperanza countered, venom in her tone.

My heart pounded painfully, each beat resonating with the blatant injustice of the situation. How could they be so blind? How could they justify humiliating and mistreating another person? "I believe no one should be treated with disrespect, not even the maid."

Esperanza let out a high-pitched, ironic laugh. "Ah, servants! What a noble cause you've chosen to champion. Why don't we offer you a reward? Perhaps a medal for your bravery?"

My mother, with a soft but firm voice tinged with tired resignation, tried to calm me, though her words had the opposite effect. "Josephine, dear, we understand your sensitivity, but you must understand that certain social hierarchies are inevitable."

My mother's words cut deeper than any physical slap. How could my own parents defend such an injustice, perpetuate such an archaic and cruel worldview? "That's what I don't understand! Why do we have to treat someone worse just because they do housework?"

Esperanza, with a cruel, calculating smile that chilled my blood, made a proposal that left me breathless. "If you're so keen to experience the maid's treatment, we can make a small trade. You take care of her chores, and she can enjoy your privileges. What do you think?"

Anger flooded me like a black tide, obscuring my vision and clenching my fists. How dare they suggest something so humiliating and absurd?

My father, finally losing what little patience he had left, strode toward me with firm steps and delivered a sharp, painful slap that sent me reeling. "Go right now and do all of that maid's chores, for from this moment on, she's fired. Now you'll be in charge of all her duties for being a defender."

Tears flowed uncontrollably from my eyes, a bitter mixture of physical pain and a profound sense of injustice, cruelty, and humiliation. I got up from the floor, staggering and disoriented, and headed for the door, feeling every accusing stare fixed on my back.

As I crossed the threshold, I found Mrs. Álvarez waiting for me in the hallway, her eyes filled with fear and silent gratitude. We hugged tightly, finding a brief mutual solace in the midst of so much injustice. "Thank you, miss. No one has ever done anything like this for me," she whispered, her voice cracking with emotion.

"You don't have to thank me. No one deserves to be treated like this," I replied, my voice still trembling, feeling the weight of her gratitude and the bitterness of my own helplessness.

As I left the house, the freshness of the night air hit my face like an invisible slap, a stinging contrast to the stifling atmosphere of the kitchen. Every cell in my body trembled with adrenaline and indignation. I felt as if I had just escaped from a tangible nightmare, where cruelty and injustice reigned unashamedly. My cheeks burned with a stinging fire, the physical echo of the slaps I'd received, and a dull, stabbing pain radiated from the base of my skull, reminding me of the violent blow against the counter. A boiling anger bubbled inside me, a volcano about to erupt, but beneath that rage throbbed a deep sadness, a sense of desolation at my own family's brutality. I couldn't believe the vileness of what had just happened, the coldness with which they had defended the indefensible.

In the midst of my daze, I spotted the imposing figure of one of the bodyguards discreetly patrolling the grounds of the mansion. Taking advantage of his proximity, I gathered what little composure I had left. In a voice I tried to keep calm and even, striving to appear normal, which I didn't feel at all, I asked him for an immense favor. I explained that I needed a journal as soon as possible and begged her to discreetly leave it on the desk in my room when she had it. Her expressionless face betrayed no emotion, but she nodded with a small nod, a small spark of hope igniting in my chest at her silent acceptance.

With heavy steps and an aching body, I headed to the kitchen, the epicenter of the storm that had just rocked my world. I began to perform Mrs. Alvarez's unfinished business, each movement slow and laden with silent resentment. I felt my muscles tense with frustration and my mind wander endlessly, reliving every word, every gesture of contempt. I thought about the blatant injustice I had witnessed, the dignity with which Mrs. Alvarez had endured the humiliation. With each rag I wiped repeatedly across the cold floor, I felt I was not only cleaning away the physical filth, but also attempting to purify my own soul of bitterness and anger.

I clumsily vacuumed the Persian rug in the adjoining living room, the machine's monotonous hum filling the oppressive silence. Dust rose in small, dancing clouds, caught in the weak rays of sunlight that filtered palely through the closed curtains. With each stroke, I felt a little of myself slipping away, as if I were letting go of a part of my essence in the physical effort and humiliation. My hands, soon covered with incipient blisters, ached with every grip, with every repetitive movement, but I didn't stop. It was a form of punishment, yes, but also a way to atone for my helplessness.

The injustice consumed me from within, a slow fire that burned my insides. Why me? Had I done something wrong by defending someone who was just doing their job? Thousands of piercing questions and waves of conflicting feelings flowed relentlessly through my mind, like a raging sea in the midst of a storm.

Every time I inevitably ran into Esperanza in the hallway, I felt a sharp, cold pang in my heart. Her disdainful stare, her eyes scrutinizing me with disdain, and her sarcastic comments were constant reminders of my place in this family, of my audacity in challenging her authority. "Look who's here, the great defender of the poor," she would say with a cruel, mocking smile, her words like invisible daggers stabbing into my core.

Despite the humiliation and exhaustion, a spark of rebellion refused to die inside me. I wouldn't allow myself to be defeated. With each move, with each completed task, my determination quietly grew. I cleaned the windows until they sparkled, letting the sun, albeit filtered, bathe my face with a silent promise of a different future. A future where I would be free, where I could live my own life, far from the oppressive shadow of my family. I wasn't going to let them turn me into a shadow of what I was.

Finally, I finished cleaning the last window of the imposing mansion. It was 8:30 at night, and exhaustion weighed on my bones like molten lead. Yet the lingering rage kept me going, a taut spring that kept me from collapsing. I slowly climbed the stairs to my room, determined to take a hot shower, to try to wash away for a moment the physical and emotional filth that covered me.

Emerging from the dressing room, already changed into comfortable clothes, my hair tied back, and feeling a little more relaxed, although the pain was still present, I decided to go downstairs and get something light for dinner. I hadn't eaten a thing all day, and my stomach was growling with a painful emptiness. I headed toward my bedroom door, hoping to find some relief. But my heart stopped abruptly when I turned the handle and realized that, no matter how hard I tried, the door was inexplicably locked from the outside. I was locked in. A new wave of anger washed over me, more intense and suffocating than the last. I began pounding on the door with my clenched fists, screaming my parents' names with growing desperation, but only received the cold, mocking silence of the mansion in response. I felt like a wild animal trapped in a cage, powerless and furious. The darkness of the night seeped insidiously through the narrow slits in the heavy curtains, casting dancing, menacing shadows on the walls of my prison. My body exhausted and my spirit shattered, I slowly sank to the floor, my back against the cold wood of the door. I hugged my knees tightly, burying my face between them in an attempt to block out the outside world. A painful lump formed in my throat, and a whirlwind of conflicting emotions shook me violently, until I finally let the tears flow freely, silent at first, then turning into bitter sobs. The injustice of the situation overwhelmed me, crushing me beneath its weight. How had it come to this?

I vividly remembered Mrs. Álvarez's horrified face the moment my father said goodbye to her, her gaze filled with disbelief and pain. She had been like a second mother to me, always kind, loving, and patient, offering a warmth that was often lacking in my own home. And now, thanks to my clumsy intervention, she found herself jobless, deprived of her livelihood, and likely facing an uncertain future. Guilt and helplessness consumed me, a slow poison spreading throughout my being.

I continued to cry helplessly, my body wracked by silent spasms. I screamed, pleading to be taken out, pounding the palm of my hand on the door with diminishing strength. Hunger was a constant sting in my empty stomach, and a huge lump of anguish tightened my throat, preventing me from breathing normally. I don't know the exact moment it happened, but the lethal combination of extreme physical fatigue and emotional exhaustion finally overcame me, and I fell asleep on the cold floor, curled up in a fetal position, with the bitter taste of injustice as my last conscious memory.

More Chapters